How Does a 50/50 Claim Affect Insurance Premiums
January 27, 2025
Categories:
Navigating the world of car insurance claims can be tricky, especially when a 50/50 claim is involved. These claims arise when both parties involved in an accident share equal responsibility for the incident. While this resolution might seem fair, it can have implications for your insurance premiums.
In this guide, we’ll explain how a 50/50 claim affects insurance premiums, the process for handling such claims, and steps you can take to minimise the impact on your rates.
A 50/50 claim occurs when an accident investigation concludes that the fault is equally shared between the two drivers involved. This type of claim typically arises when there is insufficient evidence to establish clear liability, or when both parties contributed to the incident in some way.
Insurance companies determine fault by reviewing evidence such as:
When evidence is inconclusive or conflicting, insurers may decide to split liability evenly. This means both drivers bear half the responsibility for the damages or injuries caused, with each party’s insurer covering 50% of the costs.
Being involved in a 50/50 claim can influence your insurance premiums in several ways:
Insurance companies use claims history to assess risk. Even if you’re only partially at fault, being involved in an accident signals to insurers that you could pose a higher risk in the future. This perception often results in higher premiums when you renew your policy.
A 50/50 claim usually affects your no-claims discount (NCD), which is a key factor in determining premiums. Since liability is shared, insurers treat it as a partial claim, leading to a reduction in your NCD unless you have purchased NCD protection.
Following a 50/50 claim, you may see an increase in your premiums. While the exact amount depends on your insurer, your driving history, and the severity of the claim, premium hikes are common due to the added risk factor in your record.
If you find yourself involved in a 50/50 claim, understanding the process can help you navigate it more effectively:
Notify your insurer as soon as possible after the accident. Provide all relevant details, including photographs, contact information for the other driver, and any witness statements.
Once the claim is filed, the involved insurers will investigate and negotiate liability. This process often involves reviewing evidence and reaching a resolution on the percentage of fault assigned to each party.
Although a 50/50 claim may increase your premiums, there are ways to reduce its impact:
Opt for a policy that includes features like NCD protection or legal cover. These options can help shield you from significant premium hikes following a claim.
Gather as much evidence as possible at the scene, including photographs, videos, and witness contact details. Solid evidence can help dispute fault or reduce your liability. For guidance, check out our tips on how to prove who’s at fault in a traffic accident.
If you believe fault has been incorrectly assigned, seeking legal advice can help you challenge the decision. An experienced solicitor can guide you through the appeals process and provide valuable support.
There are several myths surrounding 50/50 claims that can lead to misunderstandings:
While liability is split evenly in a 50/50 claim, this doesn’t necessarily mean both parties are equally at fault. It often reflects a lack of sufficient evidence to assign full responsibility to one driver.
If you’re involved in a non-fault accident, explore your options for non fault accident compensation.
Many drivers mistakenly believe that partial fault won’t impact their premiums. However, insurers view any claim, regardless of fault, as an indicator of increased risk.
In addition to the 50/50 claim itself, other factors can influence your premiums:
A history of accidents or claims, even minor ones, can lead to higher premiums. Insurers may view drivers with multiple claims as higher risk.
The cost of the claim can also affect your premiums. Higher claim amounts often result in greater increases in premiums due to the financial risk involved.
Different insurers have varying policies regarding 50/50 claims and how they impact premiums. Shopping around for a new policy may help you find a better rate.
A 50/50 claim can affect your insurance premiums by reducing your no-claims discount and increasing your perceived risk as a driver. However, by understanding the process and taking proactive steps—like gathering strong evidence and choosing the right policy—you can minimise its impact.
With the right approach, you can navigate a 50/50 claim confidently and ensure it has minimal impact on your financial and driving record.
